Puzzle Pirates is a pirate MMO from Three Rings Design, released in December 2003. Since 2016 it has been run by Grey Havens, a team of former Three Rings staff, and it has been free on Steam since 2011.

Every pirate job is a puzzle: sailing, gunnery, swordfighting, shipbuilding, foraging, treasure hunting — over twenty mini-games in all. Your success depends on how well you solve them rather than on character level. Players join crews, buy ships, run shops, produce trade goods, and a flag that holds an island can make its leader governor.

It suits puzzle lovers who enjoy slow crew life. The visuals are from the 2000s, and if the mini-games themselves don't click, nothing else will hold you.